I’ve stopped downloading illegal music. Not due to the
demise of Pirate Bay. Because of Spotify. When will the entertainment industry
understand that in order to overcome illegal downloading you simply have to offer
a better alternative? At the moment it’s like trying to get drugs in London.
It’s illegal, but no one really minds. You have to get it from a dealer, which
probably means participating in the only criminal activity you get up to. When
you’re in Amsterdam you buy your drugs from a shop. It’s safer, easier and you
know what you’re getting. As soon as we can get music and films as quickly and
as easily as we like, for the price we are prepared to pay, the torrent dealers
will be over. If people could buy fair trade cocaine from Lidl they would.
Why has Pirate Bay been shut down anyway and not all
the other places you can find illegal torrents? Like urmm Google for instance? What’s the difference between Google, Pirate Bay and Amazon?
They’re private companies that act as shop windows for information, torrents
and books.
Pirate Bay is the most specialized store. It’s the
place to go for illegal torrents. That’s all they stock. This makes them the
local drug dealer. You know exactly what you’re getting from them and they know
what they’re selling you. As what they’re solely dealing in is illegal they are
liable to prosecution and so are you. It is easy to put them in jail.
Amazon is less specialized than Pirate Bay but its
focus is still pretty narrow. They stock books and stuff like say a newsagents.
The majority of customers are average people after average stuff. They stock
some porn mags and adult orientated material but these are tucked away on the
top shelf. Unless you’re looking for it you probably won’t find Shaving Ryan’s
Privates. This is just the same as
hiding gay books and erotic literature on Amazon away from the general
bestseller lists. Generally you don’t find razzle next to the lemonade.
Google is a massive shopping plaza. You can get
anything there. You can find the same torrents that are on pirate bay just as
you can find some weed in a shopping centre. There’s also kids stores and
anything else you can imagine. Google shopping centre likes to talk about the
variety of options available in their mall but they don’t like to talk about
the drug dealers and porn shops that are also there.
When you go to Google’s headquarters they have a
massive screen with all the live searches from around the world displayed in
real time. All the naughty stuff is removed however. So they’re ashamed of it?
Bet they’re not so shy of all the cash it generates. Take away the porn and the
illegal stuff from Google I wonder how much they’re traffic and ad revenue
would fall?
So why doesn’t Google take responsibility for all the
illegal stuff you can find using it? And why is Amazon in trouble for hiding
the porn? Google is still a private company, a private shopping mall but we all
treat it like it’s a public place where we can wander at will and they hold no
responsibility for what we might find there. Its up to the consumer to choose
what he looks for.
You can of course set up Google to Safe Search only
just as you might not go out after 10pm to avoid the drug dealers. So why not
block all illegal torrents and the like. We could even take it a step further,
get all Chinese on the internet’s arse. Block anything that doesn’t agree with
our philosophies and jurisdictions.
The trouble is most people agree that censorship is
wrong and Google is seen as being a democratic window to the world. It would be
wrong to restrict it because who’s to judge what’s right and wrong.
So what Pirate Bay is guilty of is actually acute
specialization. It’s too easy to find the naughty stuff and there's not enough nice
stuff on offer to cloak it all in.
This is like saying it’s ok if you design a search
engine that let’s you find illegal stuff but don’t make it too easy. This is
exactly the same as those neighbourhoods who go crazy when a strip joint or gay
club opens up on their street.
“we’ve nothing against these people but not round here ok?”
Pirate Bay has just been giving people what they want.
They’ve just been far too good at it. Shutting it down is not gonna change
anything, just as closing down Napster didn’t sell a load of Metallica albums.
People want to be able to get the tunes and films and whatever else they want,
easily and very very cheaply.
I don’t believe people want stuff for free. Maybe a
few years ago but now I think most people understand that that if you don’t put
money into things you get shit back. People have watched their favourite
bands/tv shows fold and they understand these things need money to continue.
If you close down pirate bay you just make it a little
harder to find illegal torrents for a while. When your local drug dealer gets
pinched, you have to hang around in new neighbourhoods till you find a new one.
Don’t fight it. Legalise it.
The photo by the way is of a newsagent I just went
into. The adult magazines all seemed to be racked about 2 foot off the floor. The
people who were so outraged by Amazon last week must own it.